Moving along to the last US retailer with store exclusives, here is the (work in progress) list of 'hard-to-find' sets for Toys R Us. As with the other two related threads, any help completing the list would be very much appreciated. (Somehow I imagine this one becoming quite large very quickly.... )

Prices shown are based on actual retail; not the typical inflated ones.

Creator

5771 - Hillside House $69.99 (2011)

The Hobbit

30212 - Mirkwood Elf Guard $3.99 (2012)

79004 - Barrel Escape $39.99 (2012)

City

7848 - Toys R Us Truck $44.99 (2010)

3658 - Police Helicopter $34.99 (2011)

4642 - Fishing Boat $19.99 (2011)

4438 - Robber's Hideout $39.99 (2012)

4430 - Fire Transporter $49.99 (2012)

4207 - City Garage $119.99 (2012)

60009 - Helicopter Arrest $49.99 (2013)

60026 - Town Square $119.99 (2013)

Star Wars

7680 - The Twilight $99.99 (2008)

7681 - Separatist Spider Droid $29.99 (2008)

7752 - Count Dooku's Solar Sailer $54.99 (2009)

7754 - Home One Mon Calimari Star Cruiser $109.99 (2009)

8091 - Republic Swamp Speeder $29.99 (2010)

8129 - AT-AT Walker $109.99 (2010)

7869 - Battle for Geonosis $39.99 (2011)

7879 - Hoth Echo Base $89.99 (2011)

9495 - Gold Leader's Y-wing Starfighter $49.99 (2012)

9526 - Palpatine's Arrest $89.99 (2012)

75014 - Battle of Hoth $49.99 (2013)

75025 - Jedi Defender-class Cruiser $89.99 (2013)

75046 - Coruscant Police Gunship $49.99 (2014)

Aqua Raiders

7776 - The Shipwreck $24.99 (2007)

Atlantis

8079 - Shadow Snapper $29.99 (2010)

Power Miners

8707 - Boulder Blaster $26.99 (2009)

8709 - Underground Mining Station $79.99 (2009)

Dino

5888 - Ocean Interceptor $34.99 (2011)

Ninjago

2521 - Lightning Dragon Battle $79.99 (2011)

9457 - Fangpyre Wrecking Ball $49.99 (2012)

Legends of Chima

70011 - Eagles' Castle $34.99 (2013

70014 - The Croc Swamp Base $69.99 (2013)

70134 - Lavertus' Outland Base $59.99 (2014)

The Lego Movie

70813 - Rescue Reinforcements $69.99 (2014)

Super Heroes

6857 - Dynamic Duo Funhouse Escape $39.99 (2011)

Indiana Jones

7628 - Peril in Peru $49.99 (2008)

Toy Story

7599 - Garbage Truck $49.99 (2010)

Cars

8679 - Tokyo International Circuit $89.99 (2011)

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

79105 - Baxter Robot Rampage $39.99 (2013)

79122 - Shredder's Lair Rescue $49.99 (2014)

Friends

3185 - Summer Riding Camp $99.99 (2012)

30107 - Birthday Party $3.99 (2013)

41057 - Heartlake Horse Show $39.99 (2014)

Technic

This still continues to mainly be an exclusive theme although some sets can be found elsewhere.

Added

 

Legends of Chima

70011 - Eagles' Castle $34.99 (2013

Oh yeah, I plum forgot about that exclusive Speedorz set. Thanks, buddy!

Yeah, I wasn't 100% sure on the LEGO Movie sets.

 

It's more confusing for some because Toys R Us now lists the Galaxy Squad line as their exclusive now that they are the only ones to carry it besides Lego themselves.

Lego City Arctic Supply Plane 60064 $49.99  (?)

Lego City Arctic Icebreaker 60062 $129.99 (?)

 

Lego CHIMA Sir Fangars Ice Fortress 70147 $69.99

 

Not 100% sure on these but could not locate them at retailers like Walmart and Target

Lego City Arctic Supply Plane 60064 $49.99  (?)

Lego City Arctic Icebreaker 60062 $129.99 (?)

 

Lego CHIMA Sir Fangars Ice Fortress 70147 $69.99

 

Not 100% sure on these but could not locate them at retailers like Walmart and Target

I'm not sure on the Arctic sets either but I haven't found them at Walmart or Target myself and I believe the Chima set is correct. Scratch that. I just did a quick search and those Arctic sets are exclusive to Toys R Us.