Completely agree. This set has completely changed the resale game completely, and the fact that this WILL NOT sell nearly as well as 10188 will have significant effects on 10188 resale value. There is a MASSIVE cause and effect chain that can take place here, that could potentially shake the foundations of Lego resales forever.
At $500 dollars, this set comes nowhere close to the 10 cent/piece price point where most consumers feel comfortable buying a Lego set. Heck, the Disney Castle is 4080 pieces for $350 which comes in below 10 cent/piece. I know we should base this more off of the weight of plastic, but that is NOT HOW A REGULAR CONSUMER ANALYZES A LEGO PURCHASE. As appears to be the new Lego pricing scheme, they would rather mark up a set to see what the market will tolerate. Then based on sales data, resellers will start to discount in order to move the amount of product they need to move. I.E. UCS Tie Fighter. This is clearly the new pricing strategy given the sheer amount of Lego's that can be had at 20% off their RRP on Amazon and Walmart at this time.
Well, when this set moves slowly, after 12-18 months, Amazon and Walmart start to get a little antsy and need to clear out warehouse space. So what do they do? Start discounting. We thought the days of 20% off UCS sets was long gone, but the UCS Tie Fighter has clearly taught us differently. What level discount will it take to move this set? 10%? 20%?
For many that don't think that can happen on a set of this magnitude, remember, 10179 was sold for 399 for a good portion of it's life cycle. 10188 was discounted a fair amount as well. If the general population did not buy enough 10188 at $400 to prevent discounting, just imagine what potential discounts await 75159 at $500.
So what do you think happens to 10188 resale value if 75159 this set is tanking to $400 dollars to move some stock. Yep, 10188 will bottom out most likely to $400 as well. Now many of you on here are sitting on piles of 10188 bought on some B2G1 free deal or some other deal from TRU or B&N and have a buy in around $280 or so, and are feeling good while the selling price is at least $500 or so. Well.... doesn't feel too good when the selling price has dropped to $400 because 75159 was discounted to $400. At $400 - $60 in eBay/paypal fees - $40 to ship - $280 = $20. Awful lot of work for $20 dollars. If you haven't dumped 10188 before, probably now is the safest time to start dumping, and probably the first year that 75159 is out, as if 75159 starts getting discounted all bets are off.
A set that when it first came out was billed as a sure fire winner, has now turned into a sure fire dud from a resale perspective. Resellers were a huge driving force for the sets valued at $200 and over, and especially 10188. There will be much more reserved buying from resellers. Consumers will also be much more reserved paying a premium for sets on the secondary market for fear that they may purchase a set for $700 dollars only to find that it could be remade and purchased the following year for $200. I've seen this happen when Art Asylum has continually retired, reissued, retired, reissued much of it's Star Trek Starship line.
Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice....