Let's cut to the chase...There is a whole group of members, both active posters and lurkers who do not want to share information with 20,000 members. We have been asked numerous times about a "private" forum. While Jeff and I do not want to segregate the forums, the people who will use this service are not sharing information now anyway, so there is no fear of losing valuable discussion to the private forums.
Jeff and I feel this is a special option and that if members want special privileges, there has to be some cost...thus the BrickPoints fee. Otherwise, every Tom, Dick and Harry will want their own special forum. Remember one thing, this site is about LEGO and making money form LEGO bricks. The site and information has been free for everyone, but as the site matures and more features are developed, there might be some fees associated with those extra services. People make money from the information gathered on this site, so why can't the site prosper financially as well?
That being said, this is not about Jeff and I making money off of private forums. For all we know, zero members will use this option and we really don't believe in the idea. I will not participate in them, nor will Jeff. But that doesn't mean that this feature is not valuable to someone else. This is about giving every member a reason to come to this site and to spend some time here. This is a feature that has been discussed many times and by charging a small fee, this gives some value to the feature in our opinion. 99% of the site's members might not want to get involved, but 1% might use it everyday. We will give it a try and make adjustments along the way...Thanks